Supporters of Lucy Letby, the former nurse convicted of murdering seven babies and attempting to kill seven others, recently gathered at a pub in London to celebrate her 35th birthday. The event, held at The Windmill pub on Clapham Common, featured six attendees who met through a Facebook group called ‘Lucy Letby Discussions’. This unconventional party marked a unique show of solidarity with Letby, with attendees expressing beliefs in her innocence and advocating for her release.

The meet-up, which included glasses of prosecco, a homemade ‘Lucy’ cake, and banners proclaiming a ‘blatant miscarriage of justice’, sparked controversy and outrage among the public. Families of Letby’s victims expressed shock and dismay at the celebration, questioning the morality of honoring a convicted serial killer.

One attendee, known by the pseudonym Lulu Tee, emphasized that the gathering was not just a birthday party but a platform for discussing the case and expressing support for Letby. She highlighted the belief that Letby had been wrongfully convicted and deserved to be exonerated. The attendees aimed to convey a message of solidarity and empathy for Letby, emphasizing the need for justice to prevail.

The party organizer, who remains anonymous, shared her personal journey of discovering Letby’s case and forming her opinion on her innocence. She described being emotionally invested in the trial due to her own experiences with premature birth, leading her to question the narrative presented in the media. Through discussions with legal experts and healthcare professionals, she arrived at the conclusion that Letby was unfairly targeted and scapegoated for systemic failures within the healthcare system.

Despite the controversy surrounding the event, attendees defended their stance, highlighting the diverse backgrounds and professional expertise within the ‘Lucy Letby Discussions’ group. They refuted claims of being mere conspiracy theorists or idle speculators, emphasizing a commitment to seeking truth and justice for Letby.

In response to the gathering, The Windmill pub maintained neutrality, stating that they were not associated with the group or its cause. The establishment clarified that the booking for the birthday gathering did not disclose the nature of the event, and the supportive banner was not displayed during the visit. The pub’s management expressed a desire to remain impartial and detached from the sensitive issues surrounding Letby’s case.

The controversy surrounding Lucy Letby’s birthday celebration at The Windmill pub serves as a poignant reminder of the complexities and moral dilemmas inherent in high-profile criminal cases. The event, though well-intentioned by its participants, has ignited a broader conversation about justice, empathy, and the ethical boundaries of support for individuals convicted of heinous crimes. As society grapples with the nuances of compassion and accountability, the story of Lucy Letby continues to provoke strong emotions and conflicting perspectives among the public.